“There’s no doubt that the use of Geomagic Control has brought us a number of very real benefits. for a start, we are now more confident that 'Our' parts conform correctly to what was designed.”
If ever there was an industry in which time compression is the name of the game, it’s Formula 1 Grand Prix motor racing.
Among the teams competing in Formula 1 is Scuderia Toro Rosso, which is owned by the Red Bull Company. And like all other Formula 1 teams, Scuderia Toro Rosso is always looking for new and better ways to compress development and production times and to increase the reliability of its racing cars.
One advantage that the team has over the competition though is the use it makes of Geomagic® Control™ 3D inspection software at its headquarters in Faenza, Italy. This has reduced the time required to inspect new parts by an average of 30 percent. It has also given Scuderia Toro Rosso the ability to inspect parts that previously could not adequately be inspected within the demanding time frames of Formula 1.
Geomagic Control is advanced computer-aided inspection software that enables fast, easy-to-understand graphical comparisons between 3D CAD models and as-built parts, or between parts from different production runs. It saves time and increases accuracy for first-article and in-process inspection and enables trend analysis, 2D and 3D dimensioning, geometric dimensioning and tolerancing (GD&T) and automated reporting in a variety of formats, including Microsoft Word, Microsoft Excel, PDF and VRML/HTML.
Pierluca Magaldi, quality manager at Sduderia Toro Rosso believes that in addition to the reduction in the time needed to inspect new parts, Geomagic Control has played a part in enabling the team to achieve the best result in its history at the time. During the 2008 Grand Prix season the team earned its most points ever, its first pole position and its first win, fittingly at the Italian Grand Prix in Monza.
Wide-Ranging Inspection Needs
Apart from the engines, which are supplied by Ferrari, around 35% of the components of Scuderia Toro Rossoo’s F1 cars - including the chassis, rear crash structure, body shell and bonded aerofoil wings - are produced in-house. The remaining 65% - including light metal castings, machined parts, and carbon fiber laminates – are produced by external specialists. Final assembly is done completely in-house. (Image right: Color map of Toro Rosso gear box. Highly accurate measurement reports are created based on scans of the manufactured part and the original CAD data.)
“Production runs for our components range from one to maybe 30-40 for a complete season,” says Magaldi. “So we are definitely a prototype company, even though the prototypes we produce are used for racing.”
Before implementing Geomagic Control, Scuderia Toro Rosso used an outside company to inspect parts with complex shapes. Parts with less complex shapes were inspected in-house in the traditional way, using micrometers, vernier calipers and co-ordinate measuring machines (CMMs).
This traditional method required collecting individual measurements at specific points on the part. Those points would then be analyzed for any deviation from the nominal as defined on the corresponding 2D part drawings. The inspection was, therefore, a long and laborious process and only a selection of points on the part could be inspected.
Today, the wide range of inspections carried out at Scuderia Toro Rosso start with a Faro Laser ScanArm scanner and a Laser Line Probe to capture the shape of an object, be it a cast or molded component, an aerofoil wing, or a casting pattern. The resulting ‘point cloud’ represents the bounding surface of the object to an accuracy of 35 microns. This point cloud is read into Geomagic Control to begin the inspection process.
“We still use CMMs for geometric dimensioning & tolerancing (GD&T) checks on machined parts where tolerances are set to a few microns,” explains Magaldi. “But in general, we use the scanner and Geomagic Control because the process is much quicker and allows the whole part to be inspected in detail, rather than just a few selected measurements.”
Simple, Fast Process
The inspection process relies on two inputs to Geomagic Control: the 3D scan data of the part to be inspected and the original 3D CAD model of the part from Scuderia Toro Rosso’s Unigraphics CAD/CAM system.
The first step is to create a single, unified 3D scan data model of the part by aligning and merging the individual scans taken from different viewpoints. The scans are aligned using automated methods provided by Geomagic Control.
When the single 3D scan data model has been produced, datums and features upon which the inspection is going to be based are created on the CAD model. The scan data model is then aligned with the nominal 3D CAD model using both manual and automatic alignment facilities provided by Geomagic Control.
The whole process, from reading in the scan data and the CAD model to arriving at the point where the two models are aligned correctly and inspection analysis can start, takes no more than an hour or so to complete.
With the models aligned, the 3D scan data model is automatically analyzed against the 3D CAD model to identify and measure any deviations between the physical part and its counterpart 3D CAD model, as well as for GD&T purposes. Geomagic Control automatically assigns colors to the 3D model, with the colors representing different degrees of deviation. Actual deviation values are also shown, along with GD&T call-outs.
Generally speaking, surface form errors at Scuderia Toro Rosso are 0.2 mm maximum for complex shapes. If appropriate, whisker plots of cross-sections and wall thickness analysis results can also be calculated and displayed by Geomagic Control.
Inspection reports are then output as PDFs automatically and sent to the research & development (R&D) department and the design office for any remedial action. If any big non-conformities are discovered, the reports are sent to the original part manufacturer for action.
Benefits All Around
At Scuderia Toro Rosso it’s all about maximizing results in the fastest time possible, so the first parts analyzed by Magaldi and his team using Geomagic Control were those that had an effect on the aerodynamic performance of the car. These included the front and rear wings, as well as their corresponding patterns and molds.
Today, the software’s use has been extended to just about every kind of part that is manufactured, either in-house or by third-party suppliers. These include cast, machined and carbon fiber laminate parts, as well as the patterns and molds used to produce them. Because of the small batch numbers involved and the automation and speed provided by Geomagic Control, Scuderia Toro Rosso is now able to inspect every part produced for its Formula 1 cars.
Magaldi and his team have also gone beyond using Geomagic Control just to inspect individual components. It is now used in the assembly process as well to check, for example, the correct insert positioning for structural composite parts.
“There’s no doubt that the use of Geomagic Control has brought us a number of very real benefits,” says Magaldi. “For a start, we are now more confident that parts conform correctly to what was designed. We are also able to inspect parts that previously we couldn’t inspect fully, either because we didn’t have the technology or because of time constraints – or a combination of both of these. This gives us a better understanding of what we are going to assemble on a race car which will help towards better performance and reliability.”